Ask Polly: My Good Friend Dropped A Few Pounds and from now on I Want Him. Are I Shallow?

Pic: David Tipling/Getty Images

Dear Polly,

I’ve he friend, in which he is actually without a doubt one of the biggest males I previously met in daily life. Inside four decades or more since we turned into buddies he has been only powerful, wise, selfless, and interestingly charismatic (the kind that DEFINITELY understands an ideal thing to express). 2 years into this relationship, i acquired a haircut that was a lot a great deal faster than I’d wanted, and I had been FURIOUS about any of it. It made me feel foolish and extremely insecure, and my personal feminine pals are kind that are looking for us to feel rather, but never prettier than they truly are. I asked him exactly what he considered it, in which he said, “Well, it’s quick, and that’s odd, but I am able to see your face much better.” He then grabbed my personal arms and mentioned, “you shouldn’t, ever before, hide your face.” These represent the types of situations I usually go bonkers for, and even though he hadn’t yet declared their purposes, they was obvious. Unfortuitously (because without caveat this will be too-good to be real), i recently didn’t find him attractive. Overweight, don’t value how he dressed up, certainly not a slob but not make really. One of the last evenings before he returned to legislation college, the guy requested me personally the reason we weren’t collectively, also because this was a friendship predicated on candor, I informed him that I wasn’t drawn to him. We very easily might have mentioned that the distance might be a problem (it could currently) or that I becamen’t ready for a serious connection (I informed everyone I becamen’t but would’ve abandoned that motto for the right man super fast), but, for some reason, i desired him to understand what made him around date product during my sight. The guy chuckled and stated, “Good to understand.”

Fast-forward after some duration, and then he has reached the very least 125 lbs much lighter, is found on their option to finishing law class, and has really dedicated to his look. I am talking stylists and manicures and $700 suits. I have been treading liquid economically (functioning my personal way through dental-assistant school) and mired in a relationship with NO UPCOMING (man does not have any aspiration, no drive and is a jerk), and then he is among the most chat of one’s personal group. He really got what I said to heart, because literally times directly after we had our talk we noticed a health club account card on his important factors.

Well, this improvement completely took me by surprise, nevertheless absolutely helped me more curious. I anticipated him to be conceited, in which he was, in a few of our mutual pals’ eyes, “the full total bundle,” but it had not changed his individuality one bit. We invested longer collectively come early july compared to summertimes past, frequently with a few products available, and that I made the decision that I would personally deliver the topic upwards again. I asked (via book) if he nonetheless felt in the same way while he performed this past year, and then he stated, “Nah certainly not. Kinda gave up for you.” I was mad. Just what had changed their brain? Ended up being there another woman that had caught their eye? We decided to go to the bar with a few female friends, but after a couple of drinks cannot get him off of my brain. I called him and questioned if he desired to smoke, went along to their apartment, and after sitting throughout the sofa with each other merely hanging out, he made a move. We had many hours of incredible intercourse. I found myself particular we were planning make relationship to the next level. The man who’d embodied countless of the traits I was seeking today pretty much had them all. Next day or two went in the same way. I might leave work, he would content myself advising (never inquiring, TELLING) us to arrive more than after work, and I would finish investing the night time. We anticipated to see him more, but after a couple of days the messages quit. Several days passed and that I don’t see or content with him. Had we scared him away? We communicated almost daily for years until that time, therefore I was actually rather shocked by their silence. I obtained onto Instagram and watched several or more images of him at a number of various outings with a girl that is pretty much the younger, dumber version of me. Same frame, exact same tresses, on your body of a 19-year-old cocktail waiter.

After almost a week, we finally talked again, and I also requested him if they had been major, that the guy replied, “Of course maybe not.” But after a conversation of obscure, uncertain answers, I finally blurted away precisely what I became experiencing. I needed him, and I decided he had been punishing me for not thinking about him before. He started laughing, then also known as me personally shallow. Stating that he could never date me because he “would need to get on a scale every morning” to determine if he was worthy of me. That his personality had not changed, hence a tiny improvement in physical appearance shouldn’t just take my personal interest level from 0 to 100. Then he went into lawyer function, showing myself Facebook posts from his heavy times and from now on; similar clever Facebook standing which had become 30 loves when he was overweight got over 100 now that he had been slim. Then he turned into upset, near tears also, and informed me that saddest part of burning fat was that people ultimately complimented him on qualities he’d usually had. Then he kissed my personal forehead and said that my personal very first instincts on matchmaking him were ideal types. I am completely smitten, and would like to persuade him that my personal intentions are genuine. However they are they? Can I be punished for perhaps not hoping the unsightly duckling, then dropping for the breathtaking swan? And is he truly upset, or perhaps utilizing my feelings for him against me personally?

Falling for buddy

Dear FFF,

Your own tale is ideal for a lighthearted passionate comedy. The formerly chubby, sloppy guy (Chris Pratt) may be the protagonist and character, naturally, and you are the super-pretty fantasy lady (
Rachel McAdams
) who never date him. The guy rolls back to community all match and successful, you swoon, together with both of you look set to live joyfully actually after. Except that there’s another lady into the photo, a down-to-earth librarian with a great sense of humor (
Emma Rock
in unattractive specs). He and she have always palled around with each other, and this lady has privately loved him from afar this whole time. Within the second-to-last world, you two tend to be bickering over something silly within vehicle as soon as your formerly chubby fiancé sites his librarian really love in a nearby car, stopped at a traffic light. He knows unexpectedly that she is their true-love. Very the guy jumps from your very own automobile and operates across six lanes of site visitors, Frogger-style, to declare their love for her. You Are FURIOUS. You chase him down, wobbling on the eight-inch leopard-print heels and coughing on exhaust. You scream at him, but the guy just kisses you regarding the temple and says, “i’m very sorry; it really wasn’t correct between you and me.” You make sure he understands he’s a jerk and stumble away plus one of one’s pumps breaks down. Hot lawyer and privately hot librarian hug, smile passionately at each other, giggle. Roll credit.

Why don’t we never undervalue exactly how significantly our very own viewpoints are molded by moronic pop-culture tropes. Because not merely happened to be both you and your ladyfriends all embroiled within this notion in the lovable, true-blue unattractive duckling whom all of a sudden transformed into a manicured company Swan, but you allowed that fairy-tale to cloud your vision entirely. All of your aggressive ladyfriends (that simply don’t like you are prettier than them) began gushing over your own pal becoming “the sum of the plan,” and you just cannot fight installing claim to him. “Hey, which is MY guy! He’s usually adored us and now everybody else desires him!” And that means you ignore their “perhaps not interested” book, provide some top-quality butt right to their door, and after that you had been stunned that, rather than being awash in appreciation at the kindness in eventually enjoying him, he wasn’t into living happily actually after.

Despite the fact that my personal basic desire might-have-been to say, “No fuss. You were indifferent, and after that you had been hot for him. The male is congratulated for his or her depth of experience when they make that transition. Why should


end up being punished?”, there’s even more to the image. Your reaction to his recovery ended up being slightly crowd-sourced. Your thinking about him shifted completely, because he got fit, seemed predestined for achievement, and began blowing money on their appearance. You’ll be able to imagine it absolutely was JUST the magic of interest which was missing out on from the photo, but the rest you compose shows that you had been affected extremely drastically just by your very own fickle preferences, but by in addition by fickle tastes of your own herd.

And I want to end up being frank: the fact you couldn’t tell whether he had been genuinely disappointed when he “became disappointed, near tears” or had been just influencing you shows that you aren’t ideal lady for him no matter. I believe he understands that, even though you never. He had been demonstrably drawn to both you and watched you as someone he could never “get” prior to, the good news is he is able to see obviously that you two are not a real match. (additionally: how it happened towards jerk boyfriend? Are you presently online dating him this whole time?)

Therefore it is very simple to contact this one, appropriate? Shallow Hot Girl has Her Comeuppance, While past Sloppy Fun man With a Heart of Gold has His payback, After that Rides Off inside Sunset. He’s the hero operating out in a sporty modifiable, you’re the bitch inside the dirt puddle with dirty leopard-print pumps in your arms.

However, if that is where I land, I then’m in the same manner vunerable to having my pea brain molded by a shitty rom-com storyline while. Shallow woman


! Lovable chubby man



There’s a lot more to look at right here. I’ll confess that my heart IS mostly together with your pal, because those had been genuine rips he was sobbing — anyone who’s dropped a few pounds and already been welcomed into an entire different field of really love and attention (they found haunting and disturbing) can verify that. But i believe we nevertheless should ask a lot more difficult questions.

Question 1: Should your lawyer pal is far less shallow than you will be, why performed he follow you around and bask within hot-girl attentions as he was actually obese? Precisely why was the guy usually aspiring to enter


superficial pants? Could not the guy have turned their gaze toward the many underappreciated plus-size feamales in the entire world, versus showering compliments and comforting you about your tragic extra-short haircut? And was


truly the a lot of enthusiastic thing he ever thought to you? “NEVER, EVER COVER-UP THE GORGEOUS FACE?” Maybe


the one who must weeping in the arms, that all any individual actually cares about will be your great hotness.

Concern 2: If the guy understood you had a crush on his manicured ass in which he understood he flat-out wasn’t interested (the guy texted that this impact), WHY did he enable you to appear over and go out before you two fuck like hell? The reason why performed he do this not just as soon as, but three differing times? If he is very pure and good interior, what exactly is with heartlessly revenge-fucking one of his closest friends? And Also For that issue …

Concern 3: If he is the sodium with the screwing world, exactly why is the guy fucking a 19-year-old cocktail waitress and texting “Without a doubt perhaps not” as soon as you ask him when it’s major? As well as how do you think the TEEN WITHIN THIS PICTURE feels about undergoing treatment like a girlfriend merely thus a callous late-twentysomething could keep fucking their?

I am not stating people of all age groups shouldn’t possess sex they desire together with the individuals they really want. I am not saying dudes are not so great news as long as they just date more youthful women or make an effort to sleep with previous crushes whom once wouldn’t give them the time of day. And that I’m certainly not claiming your own friend is a terrible chap. The guy sounds like a smart, delicate man who’s kicked his lifetime into high equipment and from now on he is thinking how to draw a line through the life he previously before into existence he has got now. He’s wanting to know ideas on how to procedure their current appeal, provided just how dipped in shit the guy always feel. I’m for him. I think he’s had gotten lots of try to perform, to come quickly to grips with his confusion over just how fickle and fucked the world are. I am hoping he does not drain and marry some empty


-hottie who fits their $700 fit, because his ego is actually running the tv series nowadays and then he does not understand where you can place all despair at being forced to straddle two various facts.

Guess what happens gives me hope? The truth that the guy resisted the compulsion to help keep torturing you, and resisted the urge to yell at you, and resisted the urge to dismantle your own value program, only to generate themselves feel good. I am reassured from the undeniable fact that the guy opened up and almost cried for you and confirmed you how hard truly for him. Therefore know what? Should you have recognized this particular was actual despair he was expressing, if perhaps you were dedicated to him as a person staying, rather than focused on THAT WHICH YOU WANTED TO WIN (the hot, total-package provider-man of your buddies’ desires), he may’ve provided you the opportunity. I really don’t indicate to throw him as some kind of valiant great man whenever I claim that. I am just saying, you


love him for exactly who he had been. If you performed, you’ll’ve obtained very quiet and shown him your empathy and acknowledged exactly how difficult this has been for him, versus thinking about your own disappointment at not getting the hot-best-friend-lover-hero-husband of one’s crappy-rom-com-shaped fantasies. You write, “i am positively smitten, and would like to convince him that my personal purposes tend to be real. But are they?” If you have to ask, the intentions probably aren’t genuine. You are in crave along with your friend, and you are all worked-up over this idea that he could be your own prince charming, nevertheless you shouldn’t love him. You could acknowledge a lot of their good traits, but until you’re also enraptured by his susceptability and his disappointment — the heartbroken chubby child hiding inside that slick exterior — you aren’t willing to love him for just who he could be.

And maybe they aren’t prepared love themselves for exactly who he actually is, possibly. Possibly he’s repaired right up his exterior, but his insides nonetheless feel sloppy and shabby, and then he’s ashamed. Perhaps he’s attempting to hold himself satisfied with shallow benefits — hot young adults and pricey fits — but he isn’t everything happy. Maybe the guy does not accept simply how much you two have as a common factor: you are both young and ego-driven and bewildered and missing, after the dipshit herd, getting cues from your skin-deep culture as opposed to searching difficult at everything


want and whom you


wanna be.

Some tips about what If only for people: an approach to reconcile the injustices around you sufficient as possible offer nicely to the people exactly who deserve it; a means to block out the idiotic tropes and insipid plotlines that make you ignore the richness and complexity with the real world therefore the genuine people with it. My personal desire is you’ll learn how to end up being vulnerable, figure out how to can be found in 2nd or next, or even better, to not compete whatsoever. My personal wish is that you’ll figure out how to matter your first impulse — to get, to beat, to have many and a lot more — and feel the right path through existence alternatively. As soon as you think your path via your existence with vulnerability, without defensiveness, without grabby stressed avarice over what you are NOT getting — an embarrassment of real riches unfolds before the sight.

Your friend told you, “You should never, actually conceal the face.” But they are you covering? Have you been concealing behind a bad date, or a profession course you’re indifferent about, or a gaggle of competitive girlfriends who don’t truly pay attention or support whom you really are? Are you hiding from that which you wish, and that is more soaring and unique and could bring you more satisfaction than being an attorney’s hot housewife? What exactly do you really want? Maybe you happened to be mad regarding your tragic haircut not since your actual hotness does matter that much to you personally, but given that it matters so goddamn much to everyone close to you. Perhaps you’re sick of sensation like a fairly woman whoever insides nobody appears to see or worry about. Perhaps you should not contend with the low herd any longer. Perhaps you’re fed up with feeling like a deep failing just because you aren’t throughout the fast track to pumping away infants to fill a huge bare household for the suburbs.

I am extrapolating, without a doubt. Only you-know-what you really like and what’s best for you. But I really don’t imagine you actually

wish to be with

your buddy. In my opinion you want to

end up being

him: strong, wise, selfless, and amazingly charismatic. What kind of a profession, what forms of buddies, what sort of an existence, just what state of grace might you reach that goal will make you think this way about yourself?

For the present time, inform your friend you’re sorry to make him feel small, and give him your true blessing to check out his very own path. After that get a hold of the correct path. Figure out what could make you feel powerful and smart. Work out how you’ll be selfless. This is your wake-up telephone call. Exactly what do you want on your own, so terribly it’s embarrassing to even say it? Just what dream breaks the center in order to imagine it? Prevent chasing after mythical company Swans, and pursue


dream as an alternative.


Got a concern for Polly? E-mail
. Her guidance line will be right here every Wednesday mid-day.

the new Ask Polly publication,

How to become One in the World

. Had gotten a concern for Polly? Mail
. Her information line will show up
here every Wednesday

Get Ask Polly delivered weekly.

All letters to
end up being the home of Ask Polly and ny news LLC and you will be modified for size, understanding, and grammatical correctness.